The real intrigue of this year’s Oscar awards was never about which film would win Best Picture or who would wear something embarrassing or just how crappy the stage patter would be. No, the real intrigue this year, quite simply, was: “How will Jon Stewart do?”
My answer: Better as the show went on, but generally lousy. (Beachwood TV/Movie Editor Don Jacobson disagrees, as you can read below.) I suspect Stewart was saddled with Oscar show hacks, not his Daily Show writers, because his jokes fell flat–and deserved to. (Exception: When Stewart wondered if pulling down the giant Oscar statue would liberate Hollywood.)
My suggestion for next year: Let Lily Tomlin and Meryl Streep co-host. They gave the evening’s best performance–and with a comic device that could have simply been tiring.
(And don’t invite Ben Stiller back; his green screen joke came about as close to being funny as George Bush came to seeing Brokeback Mountain.)
In fact, the best parts of the show didn’t occur on the stage (and I’m not talking about the film clips either). The filmed opening mocking the Academy’s inability to find a host for the show, including appearances the gaggle of stars who apparently turned the job down (including Billy Crystal, Chris Rock, Steve Martin, David Letterman, Whoopi Goldberg) was dead-on, and perfectly self-aware.
Read More
Posted on March 5, 2006