By Steve Rhodes
I can’t figure out the Alfonso Soriano deal either, except to say my instinct is that it will end disastrously. Either he’ll put up Sammy Sosa numbers and the Cubs will still finish in the second-half of the division, or he’ll get off to a slow start like almost every other free agent the Cubs sign and things will get ugly pretty quickly.
Murray Chass, perhaps the dean of American baseball writers, says the deal means Tribune Company is selling the team. Even if not, he’s far from impressed.
“[He] committed 11 errors, most among N.L. outfielders, for a .969 fielding percentage, which ranked him 32nd among 34 defensively ranked outfielders.There was talk yesterday that the Cubs may use Soriano, who will turn 31 in January, in center field as a replacement for Juan Pierre, also a free agent. But some baseball executives were incredulous at that prospect.
“They also questioned the size of the package the Cubs gave Soriano, saying it was far too much for a leadoff hitter. That kind of money, they suggested, should be saved for a middle-of-the-lineup hitter, a run producer like [Alex] Rodriguez and Manny Ramirez.
“Soriano has driven in more than 90 runs in each of the past five seasons, but in his most productive seasons he knocked in 102 and 104, an impressive total for a leadoff hitter, but not necessarily for a $17 million hitter.”
Bruce Miles, in the Daily Herald, reported on Monday, though, that the Cubs are likely to move Soriano to right field.
Dayn Perry, at FoxSports.com, says the Soriano deal is “idiotic in the long term.”
Carol Slezak at the Sun-Times is admirably skeptical, and the best line I’ve seen is the headline to her piece: “Soriano’s Good, But Can He Pitch?”
She also thinks the deal means TribCo is prettying up the property for sale, though in other reports both interim president John McDonough and general manager Jim Hendry say they have had no such discussions with their corporate minders. Then again, all it takes is for Dennis FitzSimons to tell them to go for it – he doesn’t have to explain his motivation.
On the other hand, I wonder if the Soriano deal – and the Cubs exploding payroll in general – is a poison pill that is somehow designed to keep the Cubs in TribCo hands.
Either way, this can’t be good.
Read More
Posted on November 21, 2006